Headline News
Secure Blackphone starts shipping (June 30, 2014 10:03 am)
Linux Mint KDE reviewed (June 24, 2014 2:06 pm)
Linux Mint 17 “Qiana” KDE released! (June 23, 2014 10:24 am)
7 Improvements The Linux Desktop Needs (June 21, 2014 12:48 am)
Ubuntu Phone OS

How open will be Ubuntu Phone?

Canonical announced at the Mobile World Congress (MWC) conference in February that they signed agreements with telcos in Spain and China to deliver Ubuntu Phone by the end of 2014. In their press release of the announcement, the company said: “Ubuntu is a free, open-source platform for client, server and cloud computing”, and “Ubuntu Phone code is always open, so it’s visible”.

When Ubuntu announced its entry into phone market, many people expected that would be the new Ubuntu phone which will walk on the open source path. But sadly it’s not to be. Privacy International says, “…despite hopes of a totally open mobile handset platform, Privacy International has learned from Canonical that their new phone will suffer from the same problems as their competitors by leaving the baseband closed.”

According to Dr. Richard Tynan, technologist with Privacy International, “…without the ability of the security community to examine the baseband software of the new Ubuntu Phone, the open-source nature of the remaining element may provide no more assurances than other open-source phone operating systems such as Android.”

Baseband Processor, also known as baseband radio processor, BP, or BBP is a device/chip in a network interface that manages all the radio functions, in short, all functions that require an antenna. A baseband processor typically uses its own RAM and firmware. Since the software which runs on closed baseband processors is usually proprietary, it is impossible to perform an independent code audit. By reverse engineering some of the baseband chips, researchers have found security vulnerabilities which could be used to access and modify data on the phone remotely.

In March 2014, Replicant–makers of the free Android derivative–announced they have found a backdoor in the baseband software of Samsung Galaxy phones which allows remote access to user data stored on the phone.

We know that cell phone location data contains some of the most intrusive information about people in the digital age, leaving a kaleidoscopic footprint of a person’s life. Phones transmit location data whenever a phone is turned on, irrespective of whether they are being used to make calls or send text messages and emails.

According to documents supplied by whistleblower Edward Snowden, the National Security Agency (NSA) is reportedly collecting almost 5 billion cell phone records a day under a program that monitors and analyses highly personal data about the precise whereabouts of individuals, wherever they travel in the world.

Canonical, the maker of Ubuntu, has been touting the open-source nature of the operating system, but until now it has been rather vague about other details.

Now Canonical is claiming that they are at the mercy of third-party manufacturers when it comes to the Ubuntu Phone. Michael Hall, a Canonical developer, says, “There is no Ubuntu baseband OS. None. Just like there is no Ubuntu BIOS. Phones that ship with Ubuntu will have a baseband OS, but it isn’t developed by Canonical or the Ubuntu community. Ideally yes, we would love to have open source baseband code, just like we’d love to have open source BIOS (there are some). But we don’t make them, we don’t ship them, that’s just not in the scope of what we’re building.”

Dr. Richard fears, “A phone’s baseband can be exploited in a number of ways by malicious external devices that force it to surrender information about the user that can sometimes lead to suppression of protests or even death. A closed baseband does not allow for the examination of one of the most critical components of the phone, which goes against the open-source philosophy many Ubuntu users have come to embrace. The choice of Canonical to use a binary only baseband is even more disappointing when Osmocom have already produced a functional open-source GSM baseband for the Calypso chipset. One must wonder why was this not adopted or improved upon by the talented individuals at Canonical, especially given the previous enthusiasm for open-source philosophy.”

We have seen this behavior of Ubuntu at the time of Ubuntu 12.10. Does Ubuntu believe in open source philosophy at all? EFF and FSF have been critical of Canonical’s ambition to track users’ activities. Richard M Stallman, the founder of FSF says,”Ubuntu uses the information about searches to show the user ads to buy various things from Amazon. Amazon commits many wrongs; by promoting Amazon, Canonical contributes to them. However, the ads are not the core of the problem. The main issue is the spying. Canonical says it does not tell Amazon who searched for what. However, it is just as bad for Canonical to collect your personal information as it would have been for Amazon to collect it.”

I agree that it is beyond Canonical’s control to dictate open baseband, but since any major player is either way not picking Ubuntu, they could have chosen a hardware player which was using open baseband. At the same time ‘online dash search’ is something that’s under total control of Canonical, but still they chose to refuse the requests from organizations and kept it enabled by default. In case of baseband, it was easy for Canonical to put the blame on OEM; though there are alternatives if they really want, but the case of online search does leave one to wonder if Canonical truly cares about user’s privacy. Or it’s just another company like which happens to use Linux and Open Source to do what Apple, Google or Facebook want to do.

In the wake of the Edward Snowden’s revelations of the NSA collaborating with service providers to collect phone metadata, there has been tremendous interest among privacy advocates and consumers alike in a truly open source mobile phone. One that will allow code to be examined to prevent back-door access and protect user privacy.

To be Open or Not? That is the question.

The dilemma of Hamlet is a subtle and profound examining of what is more crudely expressed in the phrase out of the frying pan into the fire. In essence ‘Life is bad, but Death might be worse’.

We are looking for aspiring bloggers and journalists for The Mukt. If you are interested, apply now!

Source: Bytegeist.com

Sahil Kalloli

Open Source Supporter, User and Promoter, Sys-Adm by profession, Associated with different political-cultural groups like Chaukasha, Sadak Natak Mandali. Also engaged in theater activities with Pratyay Houshi Natya Kala Kendra, Kolhapur. Hobbies include swimming, cooking, reading literature, listening music. Currently learning UNIX System Design to understand the philosophy of all modern OS as UNIX is mother of all.


  1. Pingback: News about Reverse Phone Search issue #1 « News About Reverse Phone Search « Reverse Phone Lookup – Background Checks – People Search

  2. Pingback: Spreadtrum Adopts Arteris FlexNoC Interconnect IP for Mobile Phone Processor ... | All iPhone Unlocking

  3. Pingback: How open will be Ubuntu Phone? | Techbait Tech News

  4. Pingback: qwxgvnmkfbrvecganfhv

  5. Pingback: How open will be Ubuntu Phone? - Muktware | Lin...

  6. Pingback: bgsvcvbhjfgmnbdvgbnhg

  7. Pingback: cnstgakrsbrmgfnrgfv

  8. Pingback: gtcnrkmxcrlaxenfmgarmfn

  9. Pingback: Gilbert Hogan

  10. Pingback: plumber Sofia

  11. Pingback: Series Microfiber Sheet Pocket CHOCOLATE B0041MND52

  12. Pingback: ElitePeoples.RU

  13. Pingback: factory reconditioned senco roofpro 4 inch roofing b00147y7g6 1689

  14. Pingback: hayward dex2421jkit cartridge filter clamp b004vjspm6 7058

  15. Pingback: wilmond sulfur burner prill combo b0079k5m5c 3657

  16. Pingback: richardson sheffield 5 piece knife natural b00590dy2m 1101

  17. Pingback: delta t5722 ss classic roman stainless b0040yqf6u 351

  18. Pingback: peterson real fyre 24 inch certified b001of1zs6 1941

  19. Pingback: yamaha rx v675 r 7 2 channel refurbished receiver b00ijh57i6 7742

  20. Pingback: aireryder fn52267a c 52 inch ceiling antique b00439t4di 637

  21. Pingback: fold down bed mechanism mount b001dsz3uk 3271

  22. Pingback: where to buy top hat

  23. Pingback: Шапка CAPO

  24. Pingback: Пальто Sinequanone

  25. Pingback: Босоножки Roberto Botticelli Luxury

  26. Pingback: Клатч Drap

  27. Pingback: king ts plus

  28. Pingback: 14 days cleanse

  29. Pingback: free porn

  30. Pingback: Click for more info

  31. Pingback: broches com esporra

  32. Pingback: pay per click

  33. Pingback: phone repair

  34. Pingback: קניית טיסן בשלט

  35. Pingback: supra footwear uk

  36. Pingback: saxophone

  37. Pingback: Arnaque

  38. Pingback: Showing Vs Telling

  39. Pingback: online spiele roulette

  40. Pingback: how to make money fast

  41. Pingback: Ariana Grande Porn Video

  42. Pingback: Electronic Dance Music

  43. Pingback: website design

  44. Pingback: Fashion

  45. Pingback: helichrysum essential oil

  46. Pingback: SEO Agency Philadelphia

  47. Pingback: email processing jobs from home

  48. Pingback: search engine web marketing

  49. Pingback: easy ways to make money

  50. Pingback: leaflet printing and distribution

  51. Pingback: cash loans

  52. Pingback: Dog

  53. Pingback: best work from home opportunities

  54. Pingback: car sale used

  55. Pingback: lundys clam bar sheepsheadbay

  56. Pingback: handy man

  57. Pingback: latest news

  58. Pingback: gold bullion

  59. Pingback: pneumatic mast

  60. Pingback: best web hosting companies

  61. Pingback: advertising

  62. Pingback: old park slope stores

  63. Pingback: mp3

  64. Pingback: Pinganillos

  65. Pingback: Web Designers in Baltimore

  66. Pingback: Maryland Web Designers

  67. Pingback: Ivy Enterprise, LLC

  68. Pingback: HHA Background Check

  69. Pingback: online sales techniques that work

  70. Pingback: be

  71. Pingback: buy north park condo

  72. Pingback: Pinganillo con Camara

  73. Pingback: Historical reenactment

  74. Pingback: website traffic report

Leave A Comment